Instapaper Alternative: ReadMeliora compared with Instapaper
Instapaper has been around since 2008, and it's earned its reputation for being simple and reliable. It's the app any alternative gets compared against.
Instapaper has polished native apps and a long track record, but a lot of what makes it great sits behind Premium, at $5.99 a month or $59.99 a year.
Quick verdict
Instapaper is the better choice if you want a dependable, minimal reader with native apps, Kindle delivery, AI voices, and a long track record, and you are happy to pay for Premium.
ReadMeliora is the better choice if you want newsletters, feeds, files, and videos in one library, with full-text search, highlights, and listening included on our free plan.
At a glance
| ReadMeliora | Instapaper | |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Always free tier; eventual paid tier | Free, or Premium at $5.99/month or $59.99/year |
| Full-text search | Yes, free | Premium only |
| Highlights and notes | Unlimited, with tags and a Highlights page | Limited on the free plan; unlimited on Premium |
| Listen (text to speech) | Yes, with your device's voices or a natural voice (experimental) | Device voices free; AI voices and playlists on Premium |
| Newsletters | Forward to your ReadMeliora address | Forward to your Instapaper email address |
| RSS and feeds | Yes, under Settings › Feeds | Not listed in Instapaper's docs |
| Files | PDFs, EPUB books, Word documents, Markdown, text, images | PDF reader on Premium |
| Send to Kindle | No | Premium only |
| Native apps | Android app, in testing on Google Play, with sharing; home-screen install on iPhone | Native iPhone and Android apps |
| Offline reading | Inbox and Library, up to a size you choose | Yes |
| Import from other apps | Yes, including Instapaper's CSV export | Yes |
Where Instapaper is better
- Instapaper has polished native apps on iPhone and Android. Our Android app is still in testing, and on iPhone you add ReadMeliora to the home screen.
- Instapaper can send articles to your Kindle on Premium. We can't.
- Instapaper's Premium listening uses AI voices. Ours uses your device's voices, or a natural voice that's still experimental.
- Instapaper has been running for many years. We are in beta.
Where ReadMeliora is different
- Full-text search, unlimited highlights and notes, and Listen are part of our free plan. On Instapaper, search and unlimited highlights and notes need Premium.
- Forward a newsletter to your ReadMeliora address, or subscribe to a feed under Settings › Feeds. The issue lands in Inbox next to your clips.
- PDFs, EPUB books, Word documents, images, and YouTube videos sit beside articles, with the same highlights and search.
- The Highlights page shows every highlight as a card, by date, by article, or by tag.
- Opening an article does not mark it read. You decide when it is done.
- Pair a Supernote, and your articles sync to it laid out for e-ink, with highlights and progress syncing back. You can also send handwritten notes from the Supernote to ReadMeliora. Each one is saved as a PDF, and its recognised handwriting can be searched.
- We're small and new, so if you ask for a feature, there's a good chance it shapes what we build next.
Bring your Instapaper library
Export a CSV from Instapaper, then open Settings › Import in ReadMeliora and choose Instapaper. You see exactly what will come across before anything is saved.
- Folders and tags become labels, and archived items go to Archive.
- Instapaper's CSV holds links, not article text, so ReadMeliora fetches each page in the background. Dead links can't be fetched.
- Highlights are limited. The CSV carries one selection per article, not every highlight you made.
- Nothing is overwritten, and you can undo the import any time.
We built the Instapaper importer from Instapaper's export format, but we haven't yet tested it on a real export. If something looks wrong, choose Something's off? Send us the file, and we will import it for you.
Who should switch
Stay with Instapaper if you want native apps, Kindle delivery, and AI voices, and you are happy to pay for Premium. Switch to ReadMeliora if you want search, highlights, listening, newsletters, and feeds in one library without paying for them.
Frequently asked questions
Can I import my Instapaper library? Yes. Export a CSV from Instapaper and use Settings › Import. Article text is fetched again from each link.
Does ReadMeliora work offline? Yes. ReadMeliora opens without a connection and keeps the newest articles in your Inbox and Library on your device, up to a size you choose in Settings › Storage. Archive, search, and new saves need a connection.
Can I send articles to a Kindle? No.
Is ReadMeliora free? Yes. There will always be a free tier. We plan to add a paid tier as well, so we can be around for a long time.
Try it
Create a free account, forward one newsletter or save one article, and press Listen in the reader. If you need native apps and Kindle delivery, Instapaper is a fine choice.
Have we got anything wrong? Tell us through the support bubble and we'll correct this article.